Short Barrel Rifles: Pros and Cons Explained

Feb. 27, 2017, 3:32 a.m.

The AR-15 is probably the most modular weapon in the United States. Due to simple demand for different kinds of rifles you can mix and match ARs to your heart’s content. One of the more interesting and complicated aspects of AR ownership is short barreled rifles. A short barreled AR-15 is any AR that has a shoulder stock, with a barrel length of less than 16 inches. One of the biggest considerations if you want a short barreled rifle is the NFA. The National Firearms Act, or NFA for short, is a piece of legislature going all the way back to the 1930s. The NFA regulates short barreled rifles, short barreled shotguns, silencers, any other weapons, destructive devices, and machine guns.

The SBR Advantage
Before we dive into laws, regulations and how to, let's look at the advantages and disadvantages of a short barreled rifle.

A shorter rifle is easier to maneuver in and out of buildings and vehicles. For home defense, a shorter rifle is easy to use and put into action. Shorter rifles are lighter and well balanced. A short barreled AR-15, once registered, can be used as both a standard size and short rifle. Plus shorter weapons are both a literal and figurative blast to shoot. You can use a caliber like 300 Blackout and 9mm to eliminate a lot of lost velocity and to ensure the round will still expand.

A short barrel rifle is going to start losing velocity in most calibers. Velocity loss means you are going to lose a lot of terminal ballistics potential at longer ranges. Loss of velocity can also cause expanding ammunition to fail to expand. Also, that literal blast can be blinding and when you trim the barrel there is considerably more noise.

Back to the NFA
The National Firearm Act allows the ownership of SBRs but does have a few requirements. You have to fill out a variety of paperwork. If you are purchasing an SBR from an individual or an FFL/SOT you have to fill out a form 4. If you are planning to build your own SBR you would file a form 1. Both forms are relatively simple. Along with the forms, you’ll need to submit a passport-sized photo and a set of fingerprints.

You can go one of two ways as an individual or as a trust. As an individual, you’ll be the sole responsible person for your SBR. If you do a trust you can register multiple people on the trust and have multiple responsible persons. Due to recent NFA changes all persons on a trust will have to submit fingerprints and photos. Trusts are now treated a lot like individual buyers.

With your paperwork, and photos you’ll also have to notify the Chief Law Enforcement officer in your area. You do not need their permission, merely a statement of declaration on your form 1 or 4. After that is done you can file electronically or by mail, and have to pay a 200 dollar tax stamp fee. Then the waiting process begins. The process can take anywhere from 3 to 6 months to be approved.

Failure to follow the rules
The law sucks, is slow, and antiquated. However, failure to take it seriously and making a short barreled rifle without the ATF’s permission is a big no-no. The penalty can be quite harsh. It includes up to 10 years in club fed and a fine of 250,000 dollars. I wouldn’t tempt fate making an SBR without the ATF’s permission and a tax stamp in hand.

How to Build an SBR
You can always buy an SBR AR-15 from a SOT dealer, but this isn’t necessary. If you already have an AR 15 and you desire to make it a short barreled rifle you’ll save considerable expense. You can also keep your rifle in a rifle configuration with a 16-inch barrel and enjoy shooting until your tax stamp comes back approved.

The cheapest method is to buy an AR-15 pistol. Once bought you can shoot it as a pistol, and once you’re approved you add a stock and new buffer tube. Stocks and buffer tubes are cheaper than new upper receivers.

Now when you take the building route you will have to take your lower receiver and place a name and serial number on it. If you go with a trust you’ll put your trusts name on the lower receiver, and a serial number. I’m not a lawyer, so I’m going to include links to the relevant information.

It’s simple
Once you get your form 1 you can build an SBR by taking a traditional pistol upper receiver and bolting it on your registered lower receiver. You can also use alternate calibers for your build. So an AR-15 sbr in 5.56 can be converted to 9mm and 300 Blackout whenever you desire. That is one of the joys of using the AR-15 platform. It’s easy to convert to a variety of calibers, even when it's a registered SBR.

Purchasing an SBR
If one wanted to purchase a pre-built SBR they could do so. This would eliminate the need to engrave a serial number. Several high-end companies are producing factory SBRs, including Daniel Defense and AAC. Purchasing an SBR means it has to remain at the gunshop until the tax stamp comes back. You’ll also have to find an FFL with a Special occupation tax, or SOT. This allows them to sell and buy NFA weapons. These stores can be invaluable if you are unsure of the process, and will often help with the paperwork.

Get Short
If you plan to go short, regardless of buy vs build, do it the right way. Uncle Sam isn’t one to mess around. This is one tax you don’t want to fool around with.

Editor’s Picks

Gas Systems Explained
The AR-15 rifle isn’t a complicated rifle and most people can build one by themselves with little to no training. One of the more complicated systems in the AR-15 is the gas system. More specifically, different length gas systems... Read more
AR-15 Trigger Comparison: Which type is the best for your build?
The AR 15 system is the most popular firearm in the United States. There are hundreds of manufacturers pumping out rifles and the American people are buying them up left and right. Because of their popularity and easy to customize nature, you can change everything. This includes the trigger... Read more
Alternate AR-15 Calibers: 9mm vs 300 Blackout vs 7.62 x 39
The 5.56 is the standard round used in the AR-15 rifle. Over the last few decades, the round has proved to be as effective as the platform itself. With that being said here is always room for change... Read more
Polymer Lowers: The Future or a Flawed Idea?
The lower receiver for an AR 15 is most commonly made from anodized aluminum. Aluminum makes sense because they are lightweight, the material is abundant and affordable. However, a receiver doesn’t necessarily have to be made of aluminum... Read more